Is
progress always a good thing?
estimated score: 5.25/6.0:
Good ideas
and good development and support, but needs smoother transitions and more even
development. Some of the language and word choices are not quite right.
Original
Essay
Comments-Ã in red color
The
nobleness & the use of progress in any field, to an individual, or to the
society on the whole, will depend on what use the progress is being put to, and
I feel, cannot be generalized as stated above.
One of the most common errors
is committed in this introduction--failure to restate the topic.
Progress
has been inherent with the human race. As the human brain developed, so has
progress been achieved, in almost all fields known to man. The cultural
progress over the ages, have made humans better and made this world, a better
place to live in. Similarly, scientific progress has been effective in
eradicating diseases, providing better food crops, facilitating transportation
etc. Literary progress has helped us better document our history and has
produced works that have made us think. Progress in communication techniques
have converged this whole world of ours, into the 'global village'.
More specific examples
would strengthen this paragraph. If
we look at the above examples, we see that they are all aimed at the betterment
of our world. Here progress is being applied for the society's good.
This paragraph seems like
a topic sentence and should be included in another paragraph. The products from the same progress
in the various fields, when in wrong hands, wreak havoc in the same society
that they are supposed to make better.
Again, this paragraph is a
topic sentence and might better be included with the following paragraph.
Sophisticated arms &
explosives in the hands of terrorists & children, science of human cloning
in the hands of scientists, crop control technologies in the hands of
corporations etc., are some of the examples of how progress can go wrong. Think
of how much better the world would be, without nuclear and biological weapons,
without mutated food grains et al. Think of how many people would not have died
or maimed for life, if there had been no land mines ? After witnessing the
destructive use the Dynamite could be put to, Alfred Nobel himself repented his
own creation of Dynamite so much that he set up the Nobel prize, to be awarded
to people who work for the betterment of the human society.
The ideas of this
paragraph are good, but they could be better organized for smoother
transitions. The example of the invention of dynamite is a good example, but
the writer should explain how dynamite was considered progress in the first
place. Therefore,
it is my strong contention that progress is only good when it is put to the
right use, for the betterment and upliftment of the individual and the society,
on a whole. Progress put to any ulterior uses should be outrightly condemned.
There are some language errors here, specifically the words
upliftment and outrightly. However, this conclusion is good and the ideas are
good.
estimated score: 5.0/6.0:
Good ideas and organization, but too many
spelling mistakes and not enough support or development for the ideas.
Alll over the world people are welcoming progress into their
home, their business and their education. Larg corporations use progress in
technology, industries use progress in their manufacture process. How ever,
when we think about in larger picture, it is clear that progress can be
damaging in some cases. We as asociety have to check ourselfs once and a while
to make sure, that the progress is not making to much damage to certain
communities around the world.
Speaking as a member of avery spacial community called a
Kibbutz, which used to provid to our poeple from the agriculture products we
grow in our own feilds, and sell in markets. When progress came to our country,
many industries got stronger, and farmers like ourselfs found their selfs
without a future for their agriculture investment, that they worked and built
for years. In this case progress has damaged a larg community, and made them
face a hard finencial fueture.
Another unfourtunate veiw on progress, is the use of
computures to entertain children. In the year 2000, when every home has adopted
the progress in computures, children find themselfs sitting long hours infront
of the compure instead of playing outside or inviting friends over. This way of
spending to much time on the computure is very damaging to thier social skills,
and even a reason for weight gain amoung young children.
After looking at a differnt aspects of progress, i can say
clearly, that progress has to be supervised. That in some cases progress is
making a big damage for our society. People sould welcome progress in many
feilds of life, but always have your eyes open for littel "land
mines" that could make an unreversable situation and future.
estimated score: 4.75/6.0
Good writing, but misses the point--the essay
represents the disadvantage of progress as something that might cause jealousy
or envy in others.
Progress is, by definition, an improvement or a gradual
development in a status of something. I believe that progress is a good thing
as far as it does not create enemies amongst people. In this essay, I am going
to clarify this.
When someone takes a step forward in particular field,
people say "He is doing a great progress!" For example, when somebody
gets cured from certain illness and shows good signs of improvement in health,
it is the progress in his health. Students make progress after working hard on
the subject. Workers achieve a good position in the company. It is their
progress which gives them satisfaction and a good pay scale. This way progress
is a thing which gives man satisfaction, happiness, wealth, power or honor.
However, sometimes this progress may be an unpleasant thing.
It can be a reason of antipathy towards somebody who is getting ahead of us. It
has been observed in the organizations that some employees have intense dislike
for their successful fellow employees. This feeling creates anger and in some
cases eventually a crime. Here starts the race and worries to stay ahead in
this race. Sometimes the situation is opposite. This means, when one of us
reaches to a high position, he could get a feeling of too much self importance
and show disregard towards others.
Well, as described above, in my opinion, progress is a
pleasant thing until it does not create evils amongst us. We should admire
others for their progress, then it is not too far from us also.
estimated score: 4.75/6.0:
Good ideas, but the grammar mistakes and
"non-English use of language" lower the score.
Some people say that progress is always a good thing. I
think that it is not really true. I n this essay, I will argue against this
view. I agree to that progress make our life good, but not ' always'.
The progress in technology sometimes give us negative impact
on our life. Since industry revolution happened in Europe, Technological
development has ever made our life more and more convenient, at same time, it
also impact negatively on the world. Let us take automobile as an example.
After automobiles were invented. the transportation has been improved very
much, but simultaneously, our environment has been polluted badly with
discharging waste gas, and situation becomes worse and worse. Second example is
progress in chemical industry and medicine manufacture. These kinds of products
provide us plastic products that have improved our routine life, such as
plastic kitchen utensils and plastic bag used in supermarket. On the other
hand, when these products were produced , a lot of waste material spewed out to
atmosphere and into the river. this negative effect is great influence on our
earth.
some technological progress will be subject to a disaster to
human being. Everybody in the world has known that nuclear weapon that some
country has kept can destroy our world many times. Majority of scientist just
wanted to provided a new power resource for people's life, it will be a clean,
free of pollution and high efficient power source in fact, it indeed is our
current useful power power resource. However, huge threat is in front of us, a
single disagreement between the super power countries can trigger the disaster.
In this case, the negative impact of the progress in nuclear technology will
outweigh the advantage of that.
Based on abovementioned, I will be in favor of that progress
is not always a good thing, sometimes it will give us negative impact.
estimated score: 4.25/6.0
Starts off strong, but does not show that
progress is bad; shows only that progress is good.
Some people think that progress is always a good thing. I
don't agree with this point of view. In my opinion progress is only a good
thing under certain circumstances, not always. A progress may encourage people
and may make people become more confident. In this case, it's a good thing. A
progress may also give some guy a feeling that he's so good, then he just
becomes arrogant and stops making efforts. If this happens, a progress may not
be a good thing.
Almost all of us went to schools. I'll take a student as an
example. If a student has been working very hard but he keeps receiving not so
good scores, he may become diffident and lose his courage. It'll be a disaster
for someone if he doesn't have his confidence and courage, which everybody will
need to face some challenges sooner or later. He is bound to lose at school or
later at career without confidence and courage. A better score is a progress
for him, which will encourage him and help him to win his self-confidence back,
with which he'll succeed.
If the student gets an excellent, better than ever score,
he's made a progress. What does the progress reflect? His past efforts, helps
from other teachers and classmates, etc. The progress only reflects the past,
not the future. Some people just don't realize this and assume they'll be good
for ever. If one stops making efforts, he's not going make any future
progresses. In another word, he'll lose his future successes.
In conclusion, it is my opinion that progress is sometimes a
good thing, but it may also turn out to be a loss if it's not treated properly.
Therefore, I disagree with the assertion that progress is always a good thing.
estimated score: 4.25/6.0
On-topic and well-written, but needs
development. This essay is essentially a good introduction.
Certainly, fifty years ago life was not as easy at it seems
to be now. Communication, technology, medicine, living standards are incredibly
different from the ones our parents and great parents got to know. Progress is
a phenomenon that amazes us day after day and it is without hesitation a daily
concern.
Our lives have turn to be easy going, not really demanding
and comfort has just become a daily duty. Computers, cellular phones, and the
most advanced technology is invading our privacy, and seem to be more than
necessary to keep us going. Years, ago their needs were not as much as ours
now, they could live, with
less comfort but with more peace, and the stress to obtain materials goods was
not a priority in lives.
It is true the fact that progress changed our parents passive world into our
daily active one, based in incomes and in competitions. It is good to feel we
are part of this new world, capable to offer a great variety of options,
capable to let us choose our best. Live without progress, in all senses would
not be a life, and the challenging spirit of men would not be meaningful with
not progress at all.
estimated score: 4.0/6.0
On-topic, but but would be stronger with more
development in the third and fourth paragraphs.
I disagree of that statement because progress brings whit it
a lot of good things but it also brings wrong ideas about our world and
ourselves.
Throughout the years the human beings have got a lot of
progress both in science and technology, which it has increased the
understanding of our world and it has made our lives easier and comfortable.
Only if you think in your home and all of the things you have in there, like
microwave ovens, blenders, washing and drying machines, etc, you can find many
examples of what man has got with new inventions and technologies. So it is
medical researches that have found the cure for so many diseases that were
before a sure death .
However, progress has led to develop many devices not good
for humanity, like the massive destruction weapons, that are opposite to the
principal right of the human beings: the right to live.
Hence, that it is important to think about progress in both
sides good and not so good things when you evaluate its role for the people.
estimated score: 4.0/6.0:
Very well written, but misses the point
somewhat. The second paragraph talks about the value of hard work and the third
paragraph shows how success can lead to complacence.
No, I do not agree with the notion that progress is always a
good thing. There is no doubt that progress is something everyone wants but
this doesn't necessarily mean that it is always good. In my opinion progress
can do as much harm as it can do good. It all depends on the way someone takes
his progress.
For instance, if a hard working person, who has been no
stranger to struggle and failure, achieves progress, he understands that the
progress he got is due to his perseverance. He realized the fact that progress
can be made by working hard. So he will be encouraged to work even harder and
make even more progress. In this case, progress has made a good impact on the
person's life.
Now let's visualize another case. Suppose another man, who
is not hard working and has had everything easy in his life also achieves
progress. This is rather unlikely but we cannot rule out the possibility. Now
this progress can have adverse effect on his mentality. Because he hasn't
worked hard for it he might take his success for granted. This might lead to
negligence in his work and this will eventually lead to his failure in more
demanding work. When the failure does come the man may realize his mistake, but
by then it might have become too late. So, this man has been spoilt by his
initial progress.
Now these are only two examples and there are many more
people with different attitudes towards life and hence will be affected
differently by progress. So, owning to the number of people on this planet it
is not hard to realize that progress is not always a good thing.
estimated score: 3.75/6.0
Some good ideas and writing, but "misses
the point."
I don't think progress is always a good thing. Instead, it
can be obstacles if we cannot deal well with it.
Sometimes, progress may keep people from learning from
others. If we take too much pride in our progress, being too satisfied with it,
we may stop improving. The thought of self-important may evokes, and thus keep
us from being modest. People may begin to contempt the other people, not
willing to listen to the ideas of others, and result in stay in the same
position until they realize the problem. As we all know, China was once the
leading country in the world in history, many nations admired the advanced
technique in China at those days. So the kings took great pride in it, and
became to be so self important that they decided to close the door to
communicate with other countries during Qing Dynasty. Then we lost the
opportunity to learn from others and we are left behind now.
The second, progress may cause jealousy from others and the
progress-maker may be isolated. This happens most in the working environment.
Progress will bring advantages such as position-promoted or salary-raised, this
may caused trouble if the workmates envy you. That will be too bad.
So, if we make some progress, we must be aware of either
ourselves or the people around us, to be modest, and to be alert with the
potential plot lying ahead.
Don’t read this..just
go thro this…shouldn’t write like this….(below)
estimated score: ???/6.0: Off-topic
Does not address any topic in particular, some
awkward language.
As there's an old saying "Practice makes
perfect",I totally agree with the statement. Quiet a few peole may
disagree with it because of its long period to make things right,and other
petty things though.
I've experienced lots of events or some meeting
situations,since I've been a captain in my class,and it was a really tough
thing to make my friends harmonious. That means that whenever I had to extract
only one opinion out of fifty friends' of mine, I felt the limitness of my
ability to control my class. Because I wanted my friends to follow my opinion
to make progress simple and easy, I usually quarrel with them,and make things
scattered and more confused.
Therefore I realized that the progress is inevitable in social life and I
changed my thought. After that, I could control my class much more easier than
before actually. Through several discussions and debates,my friends and I could
learn to repect other people's opinions and that make things much better and
easier after all ,which means we managed to sustain generosity in our minds
that made the whole situation smoothe and cheerful.
Therefore I think progress is always a good thing in
retrospect of my past experiences that I refered above.
What to write about for a good
score:
Like most things, progress is neither all good nor all bad. Progress
has brought great advancements in standards of living, but it has also caused
great damage to the Earth and its people in the form of environmental damage
and more effective weaponry.
Most common error with this essay topic:
"Missing the point."
Some essays claim that progress is always a good thing, for
example, in school or in one's career, but fail to talk about the sacrifices or
disadvantages involved in making that progress.
Other essays missed the point in another way--they discussed how
advancing in one field might coincidentally lead to misfortune, for example,
moving to a new city because of a promotion at work and dying in a car accident
in the new city. Such an event is not truly related to the progress; rather, it
is simply an unfortunate coincidence.
Still other essays did not discuss "progress;" rather,
they discussed "success" and the advantages and disadvantages of
success rather than the advantages and disadvantages of progress.